Inside Private Equity: The Five Core Criteria Investors Use To Evaluate Businesses
How Top Funds Decide Where to Invest—and How Companies Can Position Themselves for Success
By:
, Last Updated :
Feb 25, 2025
Share to :
Private equity (PE) firms direct billions of dollars toward buying and scaling companies—and every entrepreneur wants to know what piques their interest. Why do certain businesses receive massive investment while others are overlooked? Understanding the criteria that these powerful funds use can be the difference between securing lucrative capital or missing out on transformative growth. For CEOs, founders, and industry professionals, mastering these fundamentals not only attracts PE backing but also builds a stronger, more resilient enterprise.
A large Total Addressable Market (TAM) often tops the list of investment criteria for private equity firms. Even a stellar product can fail if the market is shrinking or too small to support sustained growth.
❗Tip: When pitching to investors, come prepared with data on your market’s size, historical growth trends, and projected evolution—these details are crucial for demonstrating strong, long-term revenue potential.
Key Questions PE Investors Ask
What is the current market size, and how fast is it growing?
What share of the market can realistically be captured over time?
Who is the target customer, and what are their buying behaviors?
How could the market be impacted by economic changes or technological disruption?
2. Competitive Moat and Differentiators
A robust competitive moat sets a business apart, allowing it to thrive even in fiercely contested sectors. This moat can take many forms: powerful brand recognition, proprietary technology, or cost efficiencies, among others.
Definition: Competitive Moat
A unique advantage—such as patents, branding, or exceptional cost structures—that keeps competitors at bay and preserves a company’s market position.
For instance, while the smartphone sector exploded in the late 2000s, Blackberry’s inability to defend its market share demonstrated a weak moat. That’s exactly what private equity firms strive to avoid. Before investing, they typically assess the competitive landscape using frameworks like Porter’s Five Forces to gauge the power of suppliers, customers, and new entrants.
Key Questions PE Investors Ask
Who are the main competitors, and how aggressive is the competition?
Is there a distinct technological edge or cost advantage?
Does the company command strong brand loyalty in any regions or demographic segments?
3. Strong Financials and Stable Cash Flow
A solid financial foundation is non-negotiable for any PE deal. Unlike venture capitalists who may tolerate volatility, private equity investors use substantial leverage (debt) to finance acquisitions. As a result, they prioritize:
Stable Cash Flows: Predictable cash inflows to manage debt obligations and operating costs.
High Free Cash Flow Conversion: The ability to efficiently convert revenue into cash.
Low Capital Intensity: Minimal ongoing capital expenditures to maintain or grow the business.
❗Tip: When courting PE investors, emphasize consistent, recurring revenue streams and manageable expenses. Demonstrate how your operating model can handle future debt servicing without jeopardizing growth.
These financial traits ultimately reduce risk by ensuring debt payments, supporting reinvestment or M&A opportunities, and promising potential returns at exit.
4. Strong Unit Economics and a Scalable Business Model
Strong Unit Economics and a Scalable Business Model
Even the most promising market can’t redeem a business with unprofitable unit economics. PE investors scrutinize whether each unit of product or service can be delivered profitably—and whether scaling up increases or decreases overall margins.
Definition: Unit Economics
The direct revenues and costs attributed to a single unit of a product or service, indicating profitability and scalability at the most granular level.
High-Performing Example:
Subscription-based software platforms, like Shopify, often boast high unit economics. Incremental customers require minimal additional costs, and existing users tend to stay (low churn), creating predictable recurring revenue.
Low-Performing Example:
Real estate-heavy companies like WeWork carry immense fixed costs (property leases and build-outs), and revenue potential is capped by property size and local rental dynamics. These factors can make scaling both complicated and expensive.
Key Questions PE Investors Ask
How sticky is the product or service, and what are churn rates?
Can revenue per customer grow over time?
Are fixed costs manageable, and do profit margins improve as the company scales?
5. Excellent Management Team
Even a perfect blend of market size, moat, and cash flow won’t pay off without strong leaders at the helm. PE investors want proven teams that can articulate the company’s value proposition, navigate competitive pressures, and steer the organization through expansion.
What Investors Evaluate
Business Acumen: Understanding of competitive advantages, threats, and market positioning.
Industry Expertise: Knowledge of broader sector trends and how to capitalize on or mitigate them.
Team Dynamics: Strengths, weaknesses, and synergy among key executives.
Strategic Vision: Clear operational and growth roadmaps that align with industry realities.
Throughout the due diligence process, PE professionals conduct in-depth interviews with management to assess credibility, leadership style, and alignment with investor expectations.
6. The Bonus Factor: Viable Exit Strategy
Every private equity investment must eventually deliver returns—whether through an acquisition, merger, or public offering. Even the most profitable business can become a dead-end investment if there’s no clear path to exit. Savvy PE firms focus on:
M&A Potential: Is the company an attractive buyout candidate for strategic acquirers?
IPO Readiness: Does the firm have the scale, governance, and growth story for a successful public listing?
Deal Structure Flexibility: Instruments like preferred equity, convertible debt, or participating structures can adjust risk and reward in pursuit of a lucrative exit.
❗Tip: Highlight the pathways to liquidity in your investor pitch. A future buyer (or open market exit) is integral to a PE firm’s ROI calculation.
Balancing Valuation, Risk, and Returns
Securing a private equity deal also hinges on valuation. Paying a high multiple can lower cash flow yield and reduce upside if the exit multiple doesn’t expand—making it critical for PE investors to weigh:
EBITDA Growth: Organic revenue gains, margin improvements, and the potential for add-on acquisitions.
Multiple Expansion: A higher valuation at exit if the company matures into a more valuable entity.
Cash Flow Yield: How much free cash flow the business generates relative to the initial equity invested.
Overly aggressive projections or inflated valuations create risk, so thorough due diligence involves rigorous financial modeling informed by real data, market analyses, and management interviews. PE associates often work closely with company leaders during diligence to refine forecasts and validate assumptions.
The Bottom Line
Winning private equity investment requires more than just an innovative idea. Companies must present an expanding market, defendable competitive advantages, solid financials, efficient unit economics, and a trustworthy leadership team. Moreover, a clear route to exit cements the firm’s chances of achieving strong returns. By focusing on these fundamentals, entrepreneurs and executives alike can position their businesses as prime candidates for PE funding—and unlock opportunities for exponential growth and lasting success.
Want to Break Into Private Equity?
📩 Join the rareliquid community – Subscribe to my free daily investing newsletter
📚 Get my resume & cover letter templates – rareliquidcareers.com
🎥 Watch my related videos:
